Long-term Rental Rates — September 2026 · ZIPs: 46037,46038,46040
Local market data by Estaite
As of September 2026, rental prices in Fishers (46037, 46038, 46040), in the Indianapolis metro area, range from $1,407 to $2,643 per month depending on property type and bedroom count.
The largest year-over-year change was a 11.25% increase for 2-bedroom single-family homes in Fishers, IN.
For 3-bedroom units, condo/townhomes have a median rent of $2,277, compared to $2,198 for apartments in Fishers.
What is the current rent range for Fishers, IN in September 2026?
In September 2026, rents in Fishers, IN range from $1,407 for a 1-bedroom single-family home up to $2,643 for a 4-bedroom apartment.
How do apartment rents compare to condo/townhome rents for the same bedroom count in Fishers, IN?
For 3-bedroom units in Fishers, apartments have a median rent of $2,198 while condo/townhomes are slightly higher at $2,277 per month.
What is the difference in rent between condos/townhomes and single-family homes for the same size in Fishers, IN?
In Fishers, a 2-bedroom condo/townhome rents for $1,753 compared to $1,689 for a 2-bedroom single-family home, a gap of $64 in favor of condos/townhomes.
Which segment shows an outlier rent figure in Fishers, IN rental data?
The 4-bedroom apartment segment stands out with the highest median rent of $2,643, which exceeds all other property type and bedroom combinations in Fishers, IN for September 2026.
Fishers, IN· Indianapolis metro
September 2026
46037,46038,46040
Long-term Rental Rates
Long-term rental rates for Fishers (46037,46038,46040), in the Indianapolis metro area, as of September 2026.
Apartment
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,397 – $1,514
-0.12%
4.62%
2-Bedroom
$1,714 – $1,894
3.35%
3.33%
3-Bedroom
$2,088 – $2,308
0.10%
2.55%
4-Bedroom
$2,617 – $2,762
0.43%
10.42%
Condo/Townhome
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,415 – $1,488
0.48%
7.03%
2-Bedroom
$1,697 – $1,810
0.29%
3.84%
3-Bedroom
$2,170 – $2,384
2.11%
4.88%
4-Bedroom
$2,482 – $2,689
0.81%
8.97%
Single-Family
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,372 – $1,443
0.43%
9.24%
2-Bedroom
$1,622 – $1,757
2.54%
11.25%
3-Bedroom
$2,086 – $2,292
1.18%
5.07%
4-Bedroom
$2,357 – $2,554
-3.50%
1.36%
Data updated: October 19, 2026
Fishers Rental Trends · Indianapolis metro
In the Fishers (46037, 46038, 46040) rental market, 4-bedroom single-family homes reached a median rent of $2,547, up 5.85% month-over-month. This segment showed the largest monthly increase across all property types, highlighting a spike in demand for spacious rental inventory.
While most segments rose, 1-bedroom single-family rents in Fishers (46037, 46038, 46040) fell sharply to $1,175, a decline of 11.0% month-over-month and 4.1% year-over-year. These figures contrast the growth seen in larger units during the same period.
The apartment sector’s strength is evident as Fishers (46037, 46038, 46040) rental trends reveal 4-bedroom apartments averaging $2,476—outperforming 4-bedroom condos at $2,420 by $56, with apartments posting a 9.4% year-over-year increase as well.