Long-term Rental Rates — April 2026 · ZIPs: 46037,46038,46040
Local market data by Estaite
As of April 2026, rental prices in Fishers, IN range from $1,175 to $2,547 per month depending on property type and bedroom count.
The largest year-over-year increase was for 4BR apartment rentals in Fishers, IN, which rose 9.37%.
For 3BR units, condos/townhomes rent for $2,206 while single-family homes rent for $2,140 in Fishers, IN.
What is the rent range in Fishers, IN for April 2026?
In Fishers, IN as of April 2026, rents span from $1,175 per month for a 1BR single-family home to $2,547 per month for a 4BR single-family home.
Which rent segment in Fishers, IN had an unusual change in April 2026?
The 1BR single-family segment in Fishers, IN saw a notable -11.00% month-over-month change, dropping to $1,175 in April 2026.
What is the most affordable rental configuration in Fishers, IN for April 2026?
The most affordable option is a 1BR single-family home at $1,175 per month in Fishers, IN for April 2026.
Are rents in Fishers, IN increasing or decreasing in April 2026?
Rents in Fishers, IN in April 2026 are increasing for nearly all segments, with the exception of 1BR single-family homes, which declined -11.00% month-over-month and -4.09% year-over-year.
Fishers, IN
April 2026
46037,46038,46040
Long-term Rental Rates
Apartment
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,351 – $1,463
0.66%
3.20%
2-Bedroom
$1,604 – $1,772
2.32%
1.67%
3-Bedroom
$1,990 – $2,199
1.00%
5.48%
4-Bedroom
$2,417 – $2,562
1.24%
9.37%
Condo/Townhome
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,364 – $1,434
1.38%
7.00%
2-Bedroom
$1,640 – $1,749
1.62%
3.43%
3-Bedroom
$2,129 – $2,284
1.93%
6.27%
4-Bedroom
$2,366 – $2,504
1.19%
7.99%
Single-Family
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,149 – $1,201
-11.00%
-4.09%
2-Bedroom
$1,504 – $1,588
1.08%
7.56%
3-Bedroom
$2,033 – $2,247
2.32%
6.72%
4-Bedroom
$2,407 – $2,687
5.85%
8.04%
Data updated: June 2, 2026
In the Fishers (46037, 46038, 46040) rental market, 4-bedroom single-family homes reached a median rent of $2,547, up 5.85% month-over-month. This segment showed the largest monthly increase across all property types, highlighting a spike in demand for spacious rental inventory.
While most segments rose, 1-bedroom single-family rents in Fishers (46037, 46038, 46040) fell sharply to $1,175, a decline of 11.0% month-over-month and 4.1% year-over-year. These figures contrast the growth seen in larger units during the same period.
The apartment sector’s strength is evident as Fishers (46037, 46038, 46040) rental trends reveal 4-bedroom apartments averaging $2,476—outperforming 4-bedroom condos at $2,420 by $56, with apartments posting a 9.4% year-over-year increase as well.