Long-term Rental Rates — September 2026 · ZIPs: 14534
Local market data by Estaite
As of September 2026, rental prices in Pittsford (14534), in the Rochester metro area, range from $1,418 to $2,925 per month depending on property type and bedroom count.
The largest year-over-year increase was for 3BR apartments, which rose 14.24% compared to September 2025.
For three-bedroom homes, single-family rentals have the highest median rent at $2,608 versus $2,155 for apartments and $2,224 for condos/townhomes.
What is the rent range for homes and apartments in Pittsford, NY as of September 2026?
Rents in Pittsford, NY range from $1,418 for a 1BR condo/townhome to $2,925 for a 4BR single-family home in September 2026.
Are rental prices in Pittsford, NY going up or down in September 2026?
Rental prices in Pittsford, NY are rising across all segments, with year-over-year increases ranging from 8.71% for 2BR condos/townhomes up to 14.24% for 3BR apartments.
How much more does a single-family home cost to rent compared to an apartment for the same number of bedrooms in Pittsford, NY?
In September 2026, a 3BR single-family home has a median rent of $2,608 compared to $2,155 for a 3BR apartment, a premium of $453.
Which rental segment shows the most unusual number in Pittsford, NY for September 2026?
The 4BR single-family segment shows the highest median rent at $2,925 and the sharpest month-over-month increase at 12.67% in September 2026.
Pittsford, NY· Rochester metro
September 2026
14534
Long-term Rental Rates
Long-term rental rates for Pittsford (14534), in the Rochester metro area, as of September 2026.
Apartment
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,389 – $1,505
5.23%
12.51%
2-Bedroom
$1,701 – $1,880
4.51%
12.03%
3-Bedroom
$2,068 – $2,241
5.36%
14.24%
4-Bedroom
$2,286 – $2,399
-0.17%
9.60%
Condo/Townhome
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,383 – $1,453
0.14%
9.16%
2-Bedroom
$1,770 – $1,898
-0.16%
8.71%
3-Bedroom
$2,149 – $2,302
0.09%
9.18%
4-Bedroom
$2,332 – $2,435
-0.72%
9.29%
Single-Family
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,441 – $1,488
-0.34%
9.50%
2-Bedroom
$1,806 – $1,936
-0.37%
8.72%
3-Bedroom
$2,491 – $2,726
6.99%
13.75%
4-Bedroom
$2,794 – $3,057
12.67%
12.34%
Data updated: October 19, 2026
Pittsford Rental Trends · Rochester metro
In the Pittsford (14534) rental market, 1-bedroom apartments posted a median rent of $1,375, up 3.46% month-over-month and 9.21% year-over-year. This segment experienced the strongest annual growth among apartments in Pittsford (14534), highlighting a significant price appreciation for smaller rental units.
The 4-bedroom single-family segment in Pittsford (14534) saw median rent drop by 4.4% month-over-month to $2,596. At the same time, 4-bedroom condo/townhome units increased by 0.13% MoM to $2,370, meaning single-families now rent for $226 more—but with sharp recent declines in price.
Looking at Pittsford (14534) rental trends, 3-bedroom apartments gained 0.79% month-over-month to $2,045. Despite this rise, 3-bedroom single-family homes still rent at a $393 premium ($2,438), even considering their 1.76% MoM drop, which signals persistent pricing power in larger single-family units.