Long-term Rental Rates — September 2026 · ZIPs: 44109,44135,44144
Local market data by Estaite
As of September 2026, rental prices in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson (44109, 44135, 44144), in the Cleveland metro area, range from $901 to $1,892 per month depending on property type and bedroom count.
The largest year-over-year change is found in 2-bedroom apartments, which increased 8.49% compared to the previous year.
For 3-bedroom rentals, single-family homes have a median rent of $1,529 while apartments are slightly higher at $1,300.
What is the rent range for apartments, condos/townhomes, and single-family homes in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson, OH as of September 2026?
Rents in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson, OH as of September 2026 range from $901 for a 1-bedroom apartment up to $1,892 for a 4-bedroom condo/townhome.
What is the most affordable rental option in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson, OH right now?
The most affordable rental is a 1-bedroom apartment at $901 per month in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson, OH as of September 2026.
Which segment leads in annual rent growth in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson, OH, and is growth broad or limited to a specific bedroom size?
The biggest year-over-year gain is in 2-bedroom apartments with an 8.49% increase, while other apartment types saw smaller or negative changes, indicating the growth is concentrated in that segment.
What is the rent premium between apartments and single-family homes for the same bedroom in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson, OH?
For 2-bedroom units as of September 2026, apartment rents are $1,090 while single-family homes are $1,181, showing that single-family homes are $91 more expensive than apartments for this bedroom count in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson, OH.
Old Brooklyn / Jefferson, OH· Cleveland metro
September 2026
44109,44135,44144
Long-term Rental Rates
Long-term rental rates for Old Brooklyn / Jefferson (44109,44135,44144), in the Cleveland metro area, as of September 2026.
Apartment
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$874 – $928
-0.81%
-2.87%
2-Bedroom
$1,047 – $1,134
5.06%
8.49%
3-Bedroom
$1,261 – $1,339
-2.76%
0.46%
4-Bedroom
$1,641 – $1,749
-6.85%
-4.91%
Condo/Townhome
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,069 – $1,101
0.59%
1.72%
2-Bedroom
$1,091 – $1,124
-4.78%
-2.36%
3-Bedroom
$1,508 – $1,585
-2.48%
-1.30%
4-Bedroom
$1,844 – $1,939
-4.09%
0.81%
Single-Family
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,127 – $1,162
-3.21%
-1.21%
2-Bedroom
$1,134 – $1,229
-4.23%
-6.82%
3-Bedroom
$1,457 – $1,600
0.70%
4.30%
4-Bedroom
$1,631 – $1,766
0.25%
-1.67%
Data updated: October 19, 2026
Old Brooklyn / Jefferson Rental Trends · Cleveland metro
In the Old Brooklyn / Jefferson (44109, 44135, 44144) rental market, 1-bedroom apartments fell to a median rent of $882 after a 1-month decrease of -2.65%. Additionally, these units posted a -1.07% decline year-over-year, marking continued softness in this entry-level apartment segment as of June 2026.
Among available family-sized rentals in Old Brooklyn / Jefferson (44109, 44135, 44144), 3-bedroom single-family homes reached $1,557, surpassing 3-bedroom apartments by $235. This segment also recorded a 3.82% month-over-month rise, emphasizing stronger upward movement for detached homes last month.
Annual appreciation is strongest in the largest townhome category, as Old Brooklyn / Jefferson (44109, 44135, 44144) rental trends indicate 4-bedroom condo/townhome units rose 7.15% year-over-year to a median rent of $1,978. This pace led all property types in the area in year-over-year gains.