Long-term Rental Rates — September 2026 · ZIPs: 53562,53597
Local market data by Estaite
As of September 2026, rental prices in Middleton / Waunakee (53562, 53597), in the Madison metro area, range from $1,591 to $2,955 per month depending on property type and bedroom count.
The largest year-over-year increase was seen in single-family 1BR homes in Middleton / Waunakee, WI, which rose 10.66%.
For 2BR rentals, condos/townhomes carry a slightly higher median rent ($1,946) than apartments ($1,864).
What are the current rent levels in Middleton / Waunakee, WI?
As of September 2026, median rents in Middleton / Waunakee range from $1,591 for 1BR apartments up to $2,955 for 4BR single-family homes.
How do apartment and condo rents compare for the same size units in Middleton / Waunakee, WI?
In September 2026, condo/townhome median rents are higher than apartments for 1BR ($1,624 vs $1,591), 2BR ($1,946 vs $1,864), 3BR ($2,472 vs $2,373), and 4BR ($2,800 vs $2,725) units.
Which property and bedroom type is the most affordable to rent in Middleton / Waunakee, WI?
The most affordable option as of September 2026 is a 1BR apartment, with a median rent of $1,591 per month.
Which segment saw the sharpest month-over-month change in Middleton / Waunakee, WI?
2BR apartment rents rose the most month-over-month, increasing 8.50% in September 2026.
Middleton / Waunakee, WI· Madison metro
September 2026
53562,53597
Long-term Rental Rates
Long-term rental rates for Middleton / Waunakee (53562,53597), in the Madison metro area, as of September 2026.
Apartment
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,512 – $1,671
4.02%
3.05%
2-Bedroom
$1,770 – $1,957
8.50%
5.51%
3-Bedroom
$2,254 – $2,491
5.45%
9.82%
4-Bedroom
$2,661 – $2,848
1.04%
11.09%
Condo/Townhome
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,567 – $1,681
1.13%
6.15%
2-Bedroom
$1,877 – $2,014
4.49%
6.62%
3-Bedroom
$2,385 – $2,558
-0.46%
8.16%
4-Bedroom
$2,732 – $2,926
0.65%
10.59%
Single-Family
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$1,563 – $1,693
0.78%
10.66%
2-Bedroom
$1,785 – $1,915
-1.00%
8.94%
3-Bedroom
$2,531 – $2,742
1.06%
9.48%
4-Bedroom
$2,847 – $3,088
-0.86%
10.81%
Data updated: October 19, 2026
Middleton / Waunakee Rental Trends · Madison metro
In the Middleton / Waunakee (53562, 53597) rental market, median rent for 1-bedroom apartments decreased 3.47% month over month to $1,492 in July 2026. The year-over-year change was also negative at -2.53%. This segment faces ongoing declines compared to other property types in the submarket.
The single-family 2-bedroom segment in Middleton / Waunakee (53562, 53597) saw a sharp 9.33% month-over-month increase to $1,905, surpassing condo/townhome 2-bedrooms at $1,760, which declined by 2.19%. This $145 rent gap highlights the preference shift toward single-family homes within this category.
Looking at year-over-year performance, Middleton / Waunakee (53562, 53597) rental trends indicate 3-bedroom condo/townhome rents increased 10.81%, rising to $2,493. In contrast, 3-bedroom apartments grew 7.80% YoY, showing stronger annual growth for condos/townhomes in the larger unit segment.