As of September 2026, rental prices in Otay Ranch (91913), in the San Diego metro area, range from $2,709 to $5,509 per month depending on property type and bedroom count.
The largest year-over-year change in Otay Ranch, CA is a 10.78% decrease for 3-bedroom apartments, compared with smaller declines of 4.08% for 3-bedroom single-family homes and 2.78% for 4-bedroom condos/townhomes.
For 3-bedroom homes in Otay Ranch, CA in September 2026, apartments have a median rent of $3,614, condos/townhomes are slightly higher at $3,863, while single-family homes are the most expensive at $4,110.
What is the typical rent range in Otay Ranch, CA for September 2026?
As of September 2026, median monthly rents in Otay Ranch, CA (ZIP 91913) range from $2,709 for 1-bedroom apartments up to $5,509 for 4-bedroom apartments, with condos/townhomes and single-family homes generally falling between these amounts.
Which segment saw the biggest annual rent drop in Otay Ranch, CA, and is it affecting multiple bedroom sizes?
In September 2026, the largest year-over-year decline in Otay Ranch, CA is in 3-bedroom apartments, where median rent fell 10.78% to $3,614, and declines also appear in 3-bedroom single-family homes (down 4.08% to $4,110), 4-bedroom condos/townhomes (down 2.78% to $5,096), and 2-bedroom single-family homes (down 7.19% to $3,214, indicating that decreases are spread across several segments rather than limited to a single bedroom count.
Are rents in Otay Ranch, CA mostly going up or down across different property types and bedroom sizes?
Rents in Otay Ranch, CA as of September 2026 are mixed, with increases such as 1-bedroom condos/townhomes up 4.48% YoY to $2,792 and 4-bedroom single-family homes up 7.93% YoY to $5,137, alongside declines like 3-bedroom apartments down 10.78% YoY to $3,614 and 2-bedroom single-family homes down 7.19% YoY to $3,214.
How much more does it cost to rent a single-family home versus an apartment in Otay Ranch, CA for the same bedroom count?
In September 2026 in Otay Ranch, CA, single-family homes generally rent for more than apartments at the same bedroom count, with 3-bedroom single-family homes at $4,110 versus $3,614 for 3-bedroom apartments (a $496 premium) and 4-bedroom single-family homes at $5,137 versus $5,509 for 4-bedroom apartments, where apartments are actually $372 higher.
Otay Ranch, CA· San Diego metro
September 2026
91913
Long-term Rental Rates
Long-term rental rates for Otay Ranch (91913), in the San Diego metro area, as of September 2026.
Apartment
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,560 – $2,858
1.79%
3.38%
2-Bedroom
$3,130 – $3,494
-4.38%
0.41%
3-Bedroom
$3,398 – $3,831
-11.27%
-10.78%
4-Bedroom
$5,278 – $5,740
0.90%
3.45%
Condo/Townhome
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,688 – $2,895
4.01%
4.48%
2-Bedroom
$2,978 – $3,162
0.82%
-0.95%
3-Bedroom
$3,701 – $4,025
3.89%
3.03%
4-Bedroom
$4,917 – $5,274
-6.30%
-2.78%
Single-Family
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,640 – $2,860
0.62%
6.22%
2-Bedroom
$3,085 – $3,342
0.70%
-7.19%
3-Bedroom
$3,937 – $4,283
-0.85%
-4.08%
4-Bedroom
$4,829 – $5,446
1.83%
7.93%
Data updated: November 11, 2026
Otay Ranch Rental Trends · San Diego metro
In the Otay Ranch (91913) rental market, in the San Diego metro area, smaller units are increasing in price. 1BR apartments reached $2,709, up 1.79% month over month and 3.38% year over year. 1BR condos are higher at $2,792 with a 4.01% monthly increase and 4.48% annual gain, while 1BR single-family homes sit at $2,750 after a 6.22% year-over-year rise.
Three-bedroom segments show clear divergence, with 3BR apartments dropping to $3,614 after an 11.27% monthly decline and a 10.78% annual decrease. Across Otay Ranch (91913), 3BR condos command $3,863, up 3.89% month over month and 3.03% year over year, leading 3BR apartments by $249. Meanwhile, 3BR single-family homes are at $4,110, edging down 0.85% MoM alongside a 4.08% YoY decrease.
Larger properties are highest priced, with 4BR single-family homes reaching $5,137 after a 1.83% month-over-month rise and a 7.93% year-over-year increase. In comparison, 4BR apartments are at $5,509 with 0.90% MoM and 3.45% YoY growth, while 4BR condos sit at $5,096 following a 6.30% monthly decline and 2.78% annual drop. These figures guide Otay Ranch (91913) rental trends for high-bedroom inventory.
Crestmont Realty is a San Diego property management firm serving the San Diego coastal region and surrounding neighborhoods, from Coronado and Point Loma to La Jolla and Del Mar, with select areas across the county. We provide full-service residential management and tenant placement for single-family homes, condos, and small multifamily properties. Crestmont publishes current rental market data for San Diego neighborhoods every month, including rents by bedroom, vacancy, and days on market.
Properties Managed: Single-family homes, condos and townhomes, small multifamily
Target Audience: Rental property owners, investors, accidental landlords, and out-of-state owners of San Diego properties
Market Notes: San Diego rental conditions vary by neighborhood. Crestmont publishes current submarket data monthly, at neighborhood and ZIP grain.