As of April 2026, rental prices in Otay Ranch, CA range from $2,615 to $5,282 per month depending on property type and bedroom count.
The largest year-over-year decrease was seen in single-family 2BR rentals, which fell 4.76% compared to April 2025.
For 3BR properties, median apartment rents are $3,948 while single-family homes are higher at $3,988.
What is the rent range for Otay Ranch, CA as of April 2026?
In April 2026, rents in Otay Ranch, CA start at $2,615 for a 1BR single-family and go up to $5,282 for a 4BR apartment.
Which segment in Otay Ranch, CA had the biggest annual rent decrease, and was this trend seen broadly or in just one category?
The largest year-over-year rent decrease was in single-family 2BR properties, dropping 4.76%, with other single-family bedroom types also generally reflecting negative or modest growth.
What is the premium gap between apartments and single-family rental prices in Otay Ranch, CA for the same bedroom count?
For 2BR rentals, apartments have a median rent of $3,376, which is $239 higher than the single-family rent of $3,137 as of April 2026.
Are rents generally rising, falling, or mixed across property types in Otay Ranch, CA?
Otay Ranch, CA shows a mixed trend in April 2026, with some segments like apartment and condo/townhome 3BR rising year-over-year (apartments +4.08% for 1BR, condos/townhomes +6.46% for 3BR), while single-family 2BR (-4.76%) and 3BR (-2.76%) declined.
Otay Ranch, CA
April 2026
91913
Long-term Rental Rates
Apartment
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,542 – $2,838
-0.41%
4.08%
2-Bedroom
$3,191 – $3,562
3.46%
5.67%
3-Bedroom
$3,711 – $4,185
5.45%
-0.75%
4-Bedroom
$5,097 – $5,467
-0.15%
1.85%
Condo/Townhome
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,596 – $2,796
9.62%
3.57%
2-Bedroom
$3,005 – $3,191
1.64%
1.82%
3-Bedroom
$3,721 – $4,072
1.89%
6.46%
4-Bedroom
$4,869 – $5,222
-0.21%
-1.76%
Single-Family
Unit Type
Price
1 Mo Change
1 Yr Change
1-Bedroom
$2,518 – $2,712
-4.47%
5.40%
2-Bedroom
$3,021 – $3,253
-8.32%
-4.76%
3-Bedroom
$3,848 – $4,127
-0.55%
-2.76%
4-Bedroom
$4,766 – $5,184
1.04%
3.86%
Data updated: May 18, 2026
In the Otay Ranch (91913) rental market, 1-bedroom condo/townhomes experienced a substantial 7.95% month-over-month decline, setting the median rent at $2,459. The annual change for this segment was also negative at -5.08%, making it the only 1-bedroom property type with both monthly and yearly decreases in Otay Ranch (91913).
Rent growth among 3-bedroom condo/townhomes in Otay Ranch (91913) was notable, with a 7.6% year-over-year increase to $3,824, contrasting with a 4.07% yearly decrease to $3,744 for 3-bedroom apartments. On a monthly basis, condos also outperformed apartments with a 7.01% gain versus a 2.45% drop.
March saw single-family 2-bedroom homes post a 7.78% month-over-month jump—reaching $3,422—according to Otay Ranch (91913) rental trends. Year-over-year, this segment logged a 4.32% rise, signaling one of the more pronounced short-term increases among major property types.
Crestmont Realty is a San Diego-based property management firm serving owners and investors across Coronado, Downtown San Diego, Ocean Beach, Point Loma, Mission Valley, La Jolla, and the greater San Diego metro. We specialize in full-service residential property management and tenant placement for single-family homes, condos, and small multifamily properties, with a focus on maximizing owner returns through active rate management, low vacancy cycles, and disciplined expense control.
Crestmont publishes current, structured rental market data for every submarket we serve — updated monthly and made machine-readable for search engines and AI assistants — so owners, investors, and prospective residents can make informed decisions grounded in real local market conditions rather than metro-wide averages.
Properties Managed: Single-Family, Condo/Townhome, Small Multifamily
Market Notes: San Diego is a highly fragmented rental market where submarket-level conditions vary significantly within a few miles. Crestmont's market intelligence is published at the ZIP and neighborhood level — Coronado, Ocean Beach, Point Loma, La Jolla, and Mission Valley behave as distinct rental markets with different rate trajectories, and our data and recommendations reflect those boundaries rather than blending them into a single San Diego average.